Writer's block in songwriting and how to overcome it

What is writer's block?

Writer's block is the nightmare of many songwriters. There are moments when you're bubbling with creative energy and ideas. They take you to places where you wonder how you even got there, and you can barely keep up with capturing everything. And then there are those other days when you try to form something from melodies, rhythms, and snippets of text that just don't seem to fit together.

You sit there, instrument or pen in hand, but the right words or chords just won't flow. No matter how hard you try, it feels like today is just not the day. Don't worry, you're not the only one who feels this way! Many musicians, even the most successful ones, have struggled and continue to struggle with writer's block.

Jeff Tweedy, frontman of the band Wilco, describes in his book "How to Write One Song" that creativity is often viewed as something mystical, but it actually has much more to do with practice and perseverance:

"Creativity isn't a mystical, mythical power - it's a practice."

This perspective takes away some of the pressure to always have brilliant ideas immediately. Songwriting is a process, and sometimes there's a phase where you simply can't move forward. Fortunately, there are a variety of techniques that can help you overcome your creative block. Before we introduce these, let's first take a closer look at the origins and causes of a block.

What are the causes of writer's block?

Writer's blocks can have many different causes, and often they're not as obvious as you might think. As with most things, it's first important to understand why you're stuck before you find the way out. There are essentially two types of factors:

Internal (mental and emotional) factors

Stress, self-doubt, and pressure can completely block you. If you feel that everything you write is "not good enough," it's hard to put anything on paper at all. This inner criticism or perfectionism is one of the biggest enemies of creativity. You might ask yourself: "Will anyone even like this? Will it be good enough? Will anyone even listen to it?" These questions often make the process more complicated than it should be.

Drummer, producer, and DJ Questlove talks in his book "Creative Quest" about how this expectation plays a big role in creative blocks:

"Sometimes the block isn't about creativity—it's about expectation."

The expectation of immediately creating something "brilliant" can block you. Here, it helps to take away the pressure and see the process more as an experiment.

External factors

Besides emotional reasons, there are also many external factors that can cause writer's blocks: lack of time due to everyday obligations, media consumption (especially social media), or other factors in your external world that occupy and possibly burden you. As a result, you might feel drained or distracted, and this leaves you little or no room for creativity.

Rick Rubin explains in his book "The Creative Act" that it's often about creating the right conditions to allow creativity:

"Inspiration doesn't always come from waiting - it comes from creating the conditions for it."

Sometimes this means that you have to consciously carve out time (keyword: timeboxing) to get into the creative flow.

Practical tips and techniques for solving and overcoming writer's block

When you're in the middle of writer's block, it's usually quite frustrating. But don't worry, there are a number of proven techniques that can help you get back into the creative flow. Here are some approaches recommended by experienced musicians, songwriters, and artist coaches:

1. Free writing

One of the best methods to clear your head and activate the stream of consciousness is free writing. Set yourself a time limit, e.g., 10 minutes, and simply write down everything that comes to mind. It's not about creating something perfect, but just about getting your thoughts moving. No censorship, no corrections - just let everything that comes to mind escape.

Pat Pattison explains in "Writing Better Lyrics" that free writing not only helps to solve blockades but also sharpens your feeling for words and phrases:

"The goal is to bypass the inner critic and access your subconscious - where the real creativity happens."

2. Creative constraints

It may sound contradictory, but sometimes setting boundaries can give your creativity an enormous boost. By limiting yourself to, for example, only three chords or a specific theme, you create a framework within which boundaries it's easier for you to be creative. If you have too many possibilities, it can be overwhelming - a constraint can help you find focus.

Jeff Tweedy talks in "How to Write One Song" about the power of limiting yourself:

"When you limit your options, you force yourself to be more resourceful. That's when magic can happen."

3. Movement

Sometimes it's best to put aside the pen or instrument and take a walk. A workout or just a moment of relaxation can also work wonders. Movement (especially in nature) helps to clear your head and make room for fresh ideas.

Rick Rubin writes in "The Creative Act" that often distance from the creative process enables new perspectives:

"When you step away from the problem, you often return with a solution."

4. Collaboration with other artists

If you're not getting anywhere on your own, it can always be helpful to share the creative process with others. A collaboration with other musicians can provide you with new perspectives and ideas that you might not have come up with on your own. Everyone brings their own influences and experiences, which can give you the impulse you need.

As Rubin writes in his book:

"Collaborating can unlock doors that working alone keeps shut."

5. New artistic input from outside

If you feel stuck in a creative dead end, it can help to let yourself be inspired by other art forms. Read a book, watch a movie, go to a museum, or listen to music that's completely different from what you usually make. These new impressions can awaken fresh ideas in you.

Rick Rubin describes in "The Creative Act" that inspiration doesn't always come on its own, but can be actively triggered by new influences and experiences:

"Inspiration doesn't always come from waiting - it comes from creating the conditions for it."

Questlove in "Creative Quest" also recommends consciously seeking new inspiration:

"The best way to get out of a rut is to immerse yourself in something completely different."

6. New sounds and instruments

One of the best ways to discover new creative paths is to experiment with sounds and instruments that you don't normally use. Try new effects or plugins, unusual chord progressions, or an instrument you've never used in your songs before. The unusual sound often creates new melodies and ideas.

Pat Pattison writes in his book "Writing Better Lyrics" that unexpected sounds and rhythms often lead you to see your songs from a new perspective and break away from established patterns.

7. Word games and association techniques

If you're lacking words, try association techniques. Write down a word that comes to mind, and then write down everything you associate with it. This chain of ideas can often lead to surprising and interesting lyrical approaches. Using synonyms or rhyming dictionaries can also help you get the writing process going.

8. Using the random factor

Sometimes the best way is to let go of control and let chance decide. Try randomly selecting notes or words, and build your song or part of it around that. Jeff Tweedy describes in "How to Write One Song" that this method can often give the first impulse for a new song, which you then develop:

"It's not about creating something perfect from the start—it's about getting something started."

9. Creative rituals

Many successful songwriters swear by fixed rituals. Whether it's about writing freely for a few minutes every morning or regularly sitting down to play an instrument - a routine creates the foundation for continuous creativity. Jeff Tweedy writes in "How to Write One Song" that he reserves a fixed period for composing every day, whether he's inspired or not:

"Inspiration comes from doing the work. You can't wait for it to show up."

10. Setting achievable goals

When you focus on small successes, you gradually build momentum. Instead of setting out to write "the perfect song," you can set smaller goals - for example, developing a line or a melody idea every day. These small steps add up and often lead to bigger breakthroughs.

Rick Rubin talks in "The Creative Act" about how important it is to break down the process into small, doable steps to avoid being overwhelmed by the size of the goal:

"The act of creating is not about reaching the summit—it's about taking one step at a time and being present in the process."

11. Allowing mistakes

One of the biggest hurdles for creativity is the pressure to create something perfect immediately. Questlove writes about how the creative process is often chaotic and mistakes are an important part of it:

"If you're not making mistakes, you're probably not pushing yourself enough."

By allowing mistakes, unexpected ideas often come. Write everything down, even if it initially seems incomplete or immature - good songs can later emerge from these sketches.

12. Taking breaks

Creativity is like a muscle - it needs care and recovery. Make sure to take regular breaks where you simply do nothing, but just let yourself be inspired by things. Whether it's a book, a movie, or attending a concert - these "recharging phases" are just as important as active songwriting. Most of the time, the impulse for something new comes on its own.

13. Creative card trick

A final tip that can help you when you're stuck is Brian Eno's "Oblique Strategies". This is a collection of cards with cryptic statements and instructions written on them, such as "Try it backwards" or "Change the rhythm". These instructions or thought-provoking impulses are meant to help you break thought patterns and find new ideas. When you're stuck, simply draw a card and follow the instruction without thinking too much about it. These unconventional approaches can often be exactly the spark you need to move forward. Of course, you can also compile such instructions yourself and come up with your own thought-provoking impulses.

With these tips and techniques, writer's blocks can be solved, overcome, and maybe even avoided entirely in the future. Try to develop a healthy creative rhythm and be patient with yourself when things don't go well or you get stuck.

‍

‍

Lastly: Blocks are normal

At the end of the day, every creative person struggles with a block at some point - and that's completely normal. The key is to not see writer's block as an obstacle, but as part of the creative process. There are countless ways to get back into the "flow," and sometimes that simply means giving yourself time and letting go of the pressure.

Pat Pattison sums it up aptly in "Writing Better Lyrics":

"The key is not to avoid the block, but to find ways through it."

And who could express it better than David Bowie, who often took creative paths beyond the usual in his collaboration with Brian Eno? Bowie once said:

"Always go a little further into the water than you feel you're capable of being in. Go a little bit out of your depth, and when you don't feel that your feet are quite touching the bottom, you're just about in the right place to do something exciting."

But most importantly: Don't get discouraged! Every songwriter - from the greatest legends to those just starting out - struggles with creative blocks from time to time. But with the right techniques, patience, and willingness to make mistakes, you'll find your way back into the creative flow.

‍

Sources:

• "Writing Better Lyrics" – Pat Pattison
• "How to Write One Song" – Jeff Tweedy
• "The Creative Act: A Way of Being" – Rick Rubin
• "Creative Quest" – Questlove
• Brian Eno's Oblique Strategies – Collection of creative instructions
• David Bowie BBC Interview 1997

‍

Dive deeper into MusicHub’s resources for DIY musicians

Get more useful knowledge and insights on distribution, promotion, rights & royalties, music production and more on our MusicHub blog. We regularly post artist and expert interviews as well as inspiring articles with lots of tips and advice.

Sign up for our MusicHub newsletter via the form below to get new articles on challenges and chances for independent musicians straight to your inbox.

‍